dangalanti wrote:
raymattison21 wrote:
-No, your weights reflect the overall rating you get to view…..Not gameplay. but pass catching does dictate whether a defender picks off a pass. -
By jdavidbakr - Site Admin
2/16/2016 1:35 pm
Punish receiver is countered by courage, route running is countered by man-to-man coverage, Bump and run is countered by avoid bump and run. There is no direct opposition to the pass catching attribute, but punish receiver and courage are included in the calculation about whether the ball is caught, as well as the placement of the ball relative to the receiver. The DB also has the pass catching attribute which is used in the same way if he attempts to intercept the pass
https://theefl.myfootballnow.com/community/3/6499?page=2#39933
-Above is a thread with JDBs responses on passing nuances.-
Does the same concept apply if you had a mediocre WR with decent speed and catching skills of 50+ and a punish rating of 20+ and plugged him in as a CB, he'd instantly get 8-10 INTs a year? I've had success converting fast QBs into decent RBs, so I don't know if we should all start looking for WRs who have any punish skills at all and start playing them on defense. Interested to know anyone else's thoughts.
Simple answer is no as catch is rolled last… still under the right sets of conditions it could be possible. But why?
For the most part the defender has to attempt to pick a pass off in the first place. To do that a lot of factors come in to play. So, imo the overall positioning of all the defenders is more important and this delves towards fast players with relative skills within their position.
QBs forcing quick passes will allow for timely positioning of defenders to pick off throws in to tight coverage despite speed, man, and bump skill that will get you interesting results. But play overuse penalties will drive up int numbers higher than almost anything else in any scenario. As overuse gives rating boosts to the non abuser.
And ints matter but if you want to win games you don’t want receivers catching the ball in the first place let alone taking catches for extra yards. Once you get to the playoffs against good owners slower players will be exposed resulting in an L.
Really the more I think of it due to the lack of a jumping/timing skill here defenders should be generated with a much higher pass catch rating to mimic the ability to make a timely pick and reflect the concentration needed to do so.